This wiki has been closed following a Request for Comments. Please see this page for more information.

User talk:Raidarr

Jump to navigation Jump to search

About this board

Not editable

Money12123 (talkcontribs)

Could you please merge the histories of these two categories? I think that the category should be "webisodes" rather than "Internet videos" because the only types of Internet videos that will be here are ones that are webisodes, as otherwise they're not related to shows and episodes. However, since I created the webisodes category forgetting about the Internet videos category, the category cannot be renamed to webisodes.

Raidarr (talkcontribs)

I have decided against because the history of Webisodes is nonexistent, it's just you making it and then saying 'oops'. However, I've clerked the final page moves and removed the webisodes category.

Money12123 (talkcontribs)

I still think it should be titled "Webisodes" though.

Raidarr (talkcontribs)

Feel free to start a broader discussion; personally I'm not sure the suggested name is really the best.

About HGS page

16
MariaJúlia1718 (talkcontribs)

Since the user who removed a part of the page doesn't want to say why he removed and insulted me and Baldi with offensive names, which is considered rude behavior to other users and even clarify about the judgement rule (which is not mentioned in the rules of this wiki) that he says, what will happen to him if he don't say the things he did, despite his edits he made, he will be blocked by his rude behavior, due to his insults against me and Baldi? And one more thing, the user ThisWas is a user called Donovan on Discord who was in the Qualipedia chat on Discord wanting my ban here

MariaJúlia1718 (talkcontribs)

Baldi said that the user CreecregofLife has the same behavior that ThisWas has and is possibly the same user looking at the same behavior

ThisWas (talkcontribs)

False accusations!

MariaJúlia1718 (talkcontribs)

No is not. Throwing a tantrum won't solve anything, and you wanting channel pages that deal with news that are bad won't work, since according to the rules of this wiki, only news and sports channels are allowed on this wiki

ThisWas (talkcontribs)

I was referring to you implying that CreecregofLife and I are the same person. You have flimsy evidence to back up that wild, unsubstantiated claim.

MariaJúlia1718 (talkcontribs)

It wasn't me, it was Baldi said that, so stop accusing me

MariaJúlia1718 (talkcontribs)
ThisWas (talkcontribs)

The page was political in nature. We're trying to de-politicize Qualitipedia. How have you not gotten that through that thick skull of yours?

MariaJúlia1718 (talkcontribs)

But however it wasn't about a show. Stop talking about my skull, you know I get really pissed off when someone pisses me off, especially for an autistic like me

Raidarr (talkcontribs)

This is a bizarre squabble. On the one hand Maria, you along with all other parties were acting poorly by engaging in the edit war instead of trying to get it resolved originally in a civil way (by discussion, something Baldi is the only one to successfully do on the wiki so far) and/or bringing the matter to an admin's attention. The result is poor and I can understand the heightened frustration from ThisWas as a result. You wanted his ban, he wanted your ban, it's silly. You're both pretty, so to speak.

On the other hand ThisWas, I've stated multiple times that the namecalling is not acceptable and doesn't help your case. I've notified you over discord you're going to need to improve your approach. Pick your battles better, explain your reasoning behind the edits (like above this should have been discussed or taken to another level, not a squabbling edit war), and avoid what looks like mass blanking without discussion or darn good rationale inline. Worse, as you see, has already happened on the Movie and Game wikis. I can only offer so much good faith before you ostracize yourself.

So I invite the both of you to follow up in the discussion here and work this out maturely. The party that cuts the squabble first will look better, the one ignoring advice I cannot protect from blocks.

MariaJúlia1718 (talkcontribs)

Even I could, but unfortunately I can't because I've suffered too much with drama today and I was saying that he couldn't extend to the news and sports pages, because according to the wiki rules, only news and sports channels are allowed, I understand why he wants the non-news and sports channels pages get deleted, because are not shows, but the already mentioned channels of news and sports that he says are not shows is not right

LancedSoul (talkcontribs)

ThisWas puts the delete template about average category, saying that "Average" implies that a show is not terrible enough to justify inclusion on this wiki. This is not true, because most of pages are average headers.

ThisWas (talkcontribs)

"most of pages are average headers" In what universe is that a good rationale for keeping the average categories?

MariaJúlia1718 (talkcontribs)

Because the pages of some programs that have these average headers received mixed reception, but still have several problems but they are not enough to have the Why It Sucks headers

ThisWas (talkcontribs)

Still not a good enough reason to include those pages on the wiki.

Raidarr (talkcontribs)

'average' is an old topic on the wikis that no one user can unilaterally change. The policy has traditionally been that anything average or below goes on this wiki. Personally I will accept a contention that a piece of media which is universally above the 50% mark in review sources does not belong here, while below can be placed here. It is still ultimately called 'average' either way and is in scope. Please desist from challenging that, unless you want to raise the issue at QP's central wiki so the wider policy on this can change. 'most of the pages are average headers' is not a good reason. The above is why this practice and the category exists.

With that out of the way, which other pages are in contention here?

Money12123 (talkcontribs)

Could you please restore all pages about episodes of SuperMarioLogan? TigerBlazer unfairly deleted them because they weren't television show episodes, but episodes do not have to be television show episodes to be on this wiki, they can be webisodes as well.

Raidarr (talkcontribs)

Not sure how I missed this, tbh I'm far behind on the tvshow business including what I recall was also a page history merge request either on this wiki or the other one. If you confirm this is still an active issue I can put it on my plate for later today going into tomorrow.

Money12123 (talkcontribs)

It doesn't really matter now, users are talking about making a new wiki just for SML episodes, and plus the problem isn't as big as we thought; even if webisodes are allowed on this wiki, as Blazikeye535 pointed out, the pages were repetitive. I never read them myself, but that's better reasoning than "they're not television show episodes".

SuperStreetKombat (talkcontribs)

A reception wiki solely dedicated to one show? Dunno about that.

Money12123 (talkcontribs)
Raidarr (talkcontribs)

Complete.

Dmehus (talkcontribs)

Hi Raidarr,

Can you, or another interface administrator, kindly fix the sitewide CSS for the sidebar on affected QP wikis? When I try to expand the "administration" and "tools" sub-headings, using the Classic Vector skin, they automatically retract, which is definitely sub-optimal and should be rectified. Thanks! :)

Raidarr (talkcontribs)

Hello Dmehus,

Unfortunately I cannot duplicate the behavior you report, as the expansion/collapse works fine for me despite tests on Firefox and Chrome, logged in as well as out. Without further reports as far as the device and browser you are using and any other information on access that I (or someone else here) can use to verify the nature of the issue, I'm afraid there is nothing to be done at the moment, but I've made an inquiry on discord to see if others users report the issue. If it's endemic, I must admit it would be strange to hear of it now given both users and administrators have been using the new layout for roughly a week if I recall.

There are no older topics