This wiki has been closed following a Request for Comments. Please see this page for more information.

User talk:LifeWasGoodOnHotdogStand

Jump to navigation Jump to search

About this board

Not editable

I have sent you a note about a page you started

1
DarkMatterMan4500 (talkcontribs)

{{subst:Sentnote-NPF|1=Dhar Mann clone videos|2=DarkMatterMan4500|3=Good job.}}

DarkMatterMan4500 (talkcontribs)
LifeWasGoodOnHotdogStand (talkcontribs)

Yes, that sounds fair. I am just tired of people not understanding the difference between racism and xenophobia.

RadarYo47 (talkcontribs)

That user did have good potential of updating categories, but block that user indefinetely knowing that he will not learn his lessons

ShawnTehLogoBoi (talkcontribs)

But why? He only shouted in one edit summary, so giving him an indefinite block is unfair.

RadarYo47 (talkcontribs)

Two times already

Marxo Grouch (talkcontribs)

Not enough times to warrant an indefinite block. The day-long block is suitable for this situation.

Raidarr (talkcontribs)

Shouting in one edit summary merits a warning. Using a block, 24 hours or not is heavy handed in my opinion.

Can we add a “Xenophobic Shows” category?

3
LifeWasGoodOnHotdogStand (talkcontribs)

Some pages had to be removed from the “Racist Shows” category due to being mistaken for racism towards nationality or religion. Victims of this are Hot Salad Water, Uh oh Canada, and Tomorrow’s Pioneers. Why do I request this new replacement? To avoid any more confusion. If said new category cannot be made, then I would ask for it to be merged with the “Racist Shows” category with a new name “Racist/Xenophobic Shows”. Thank you.

Wikiti98 (talkcontribs)

Yes I agree with that category. Star Vs The Forces Of Evil is clearly a xenophobic show since it promotes genocide and hate towards magical beings yet it hypocritically preached equality for monsters.

LifeWasGoodOnHotdogStand (talkcontribs)

wat

Change the second rule

2
LifeWasGoodOnHotdogStand (talkcontribs)

Change rule #2 to "Custom captions are allowed on these wikis as long as they fit well with the pages, but the main heading to use for each wiki page is 'Why It/He/She Sucks' ('Now' if the show or person's decline is continuing to this day, or 'Why These Seasons Suck' for bad seasons if the decline is either temporary or continues to the show's end), with 'The Only Redeeming Quality' if there is just one redeeming quality (no alterations are allowed). However, it could be Bad Qualities for any shows that are in the 'Average Shows' category. The latter must contain valid and detailed reasons; do your best to avoid generic stuff like 'bad acting/animation/soundtrack/etc'." Why? Because I'm tired of getting pissed over a dated rule that should have died 2 months ago. Clearly the admins can see the rules cos they seem to occasionally edit the main page. So, why not change rule 2 to prevent lame edit wars?

Blazikeye535 (talkcontribs)

We re-allowed custom headers a few months back, I never realized no one changed the rule.

Can someone change #2?

3
LifeWasGoodOnHotdogStand (talkcontribs)

Many times there have been fights over the custom headings changing, and I am sick of it! Why continue to argue over them? Why not instead just change rule #2 so it doesn’t have the outdated early post-duchess rule, and is replaced with this “Custom captions are allowed on this wiki as long as they fit the article, but do not abuse them (use them for every article, start edit wars, etc.).


Also remove the downvoting rule (26) because it is completely pointless and honestly should never have even existed.

LifeWasGoodOnHotdogStand (talkcontribs)

This is a little something extra, but you could maybe add in this “if a page has too many header changes, then it will be reverted to why it sucks” because before in the past, the ttg heading was changed constantly, “why it needs to GO!”, “why it should GO!” “why it needs to GO! away”

MasterNinjaRy (talkcontribs)

And also the Thomas Seasons 9-16 page. Talk to Master Chief and he will prove your point.

This shit still going on?

3
LifeWasGoodOnHotdogStand (talkcontribs)

I thought we already agreed 13/8 won. Why are people still removing custom headings even after this dumb ass fight ended?

DarkMatterMan4500 (talkcontribs)

I know it's a mess, and it's about time someone puts a stop to these petty fights. --DarkMatterMan4500 (talk) (contribs) 17:15, 25 October 2021 (UTC)

JrStudios (talkcontribs)

Yeah it’s pissing me off too. Please edit the rules, as I’m waiting for power on this wiki

What do you mean “the custom headings were abused”

9
LifeWasGoodOnHotdogStand (talkcontribs)

I thought the rule was “custom headings are allowed as long as they fit the page, except for shows/episodes in the ‘average’ categories”? What happened?

DoubleD346 (talkcontribs)

I think it means people would constantly change them, with some even putting inappropriate language in some or biased opinions. Plus I don't see a problem with "Why It Sucks" being the only header.

Affrey (talkcontribs)

OK, but it doesn't mean you edit every page you see fit.

DoubleD346 (talkcontribs)

They are no longer allowed as stated in rule #2. Im not just doing it just to do it. It's just what the new rule is.

LifeWasGoodOnHotdogStand (talkcontribs)

I understand that, but at the same time, when most of the wikis have the same five headers, it starts to get repetitive. Whether you think it was necessary to let headings become custom or not, you have to admit, every once in a while you will find one that is much better than the same old WIS.


Sometimes keeping it classic isn’t always needed.

DoubleD346 (talkcontribs)

Not to mention that they start edit wars, like with the TTG page, the header for that page was changed about 50 times.

DarkMatterMan4500 (talkcontribs)

I might consider starting a discussion on Qualitipedia Meta, and have everyone vote. Sockpuppetry votes will be strikes immediately and will be blocked.

Affrey (talkcontribs)
]

Does anybody know how to make more than one sandbox

2
LifeWasGoodOnHotdogStand (talkcontribs)

I wanted to make another sandbox page but idk how so unless someone either makes my page official or I delete and do another, I’m stuck.

SniperJoey (talkcontribs)

Try putting in a (insert user)/sandbox/(insert whatever)

or for example

1

2

What’s up with the “why it’s terrible” heading thing?

3
LifeWasGoodOnHotdogStand (talkcontribs)

lol i’ve gotten so used to seeing “why it sucks” on this wiki it now feels weird to see a new heading

Stephenfisher2001 (talkcontribs)

I agree. That was Masson Thief rule that we cannot have this section like that.

NJPet (talkcontribs)

The header sucks

Why are so many shows getting taken out of the “Average Shows” category?

1
LifeWasGoodOnHotdogStand (talkcontribs)

Fanboy and Chum Chum, Johnny Test, Henry Danger, etc. What’s going on?

There are no older topics